Confirming an AskUserQuestion left its tab flowing red for the rest of
the turn (owner report: ~8 minutes on a running session, with no dialog
anywhere on screen). Two separate bugs, both live-verified.
The re-capture erased the evidence the staleness check runs on. Claude
Code fires the Notification behind the dialog (measured 6-7s on v2.1.237,
documented up to ~30s), so the 600ms re-capture routinely lands on a
frame the user has ALREADY answered, parses nothing, and applyCapture
overwrote item.options with undefined. A MISSING options is how "we never
could read this dialog" is expressed, and those items stay answerable by
design, so a cleared field was indistinguishable from a never-parsed one
and the item became permanently unsweepable: it survived every
GET /api/approvals and every page reload, cleared only on `stop`, and
still accepted an answer, sending a bare `1` into a composer with no
dialog under it. applyCapture is now ADD-ONLY for options.
Nothing ran the staleness check while a page was open. It lived only in
GET /api/approvals, which seedApprovals() calls on init and reconnect, so
`stop` was the first thing that ever cleared an answered dialog. The
`working` signal now runs the pane-VERIFIED variant (resolveIfDialogGone
-> verifyStillAnswerable): the heuristic only decides when to look, the
screen decides the outcome, so the existing "working can flap" rule is
respected.
A frame that parses no options is now conclusive in two cases, and only
those, so an unreadable capture still keeps the alert: the item once
parsed options, or the frame shows Claude actively running a turn. A
modal dialog BLOCKS the turn, so the two cannot coexist - measured, a
live-dialog frame carries neither the elapsed-timer spinner nor the
"esc to interrupt" footer, which the dialog replaces with "Enter to
select". That second signal is reached by a delayed staleness pass (3s)
scheduled alongside the re-capture, which closes the late-hook case where
the prompt is answered before the hook lands: nothing ever parses, `stop`
may have gone by already, and the alert outlived reloads until the 12h
TTL. The pass is deliberately later than RECAPTURE_DELAY_MS, whose whole
reason for existing is that the hook can beat Ink to the screen.
Frontend: _onHookElicitationComplete cleared only the elicitation entry,
but an AskUserQuestion arrives as permission_prompt, so it was clearing
the wrong alert; it now clears both, matching the server's kind-agnostic
APPROVAL_RESOLVING_EVENTS.
Verified end to end on an isolated beta instance, not just in unit tests:
before, resolution could only come from the stop route (approval:resolved
always immediately preceding hook:stop); after, it arrives from the new
paths, and a simulated late hook resolves at +3.12s with no stop, no
working signal and no GET, while the pane is still working. Tests use
frames captured off a live pane and each new one was confirmed to fail
against the old behaviour.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Codeman maintainer
7fc4784d0f