mirror of
https://github.com/Ark0N/Codeman.git
synced 2026-09-30 12:39:42 +02:00
fix(deepseek): review-driven hardening across the harness integration
Fifteen review findings on the dsh mode, the serious ones first: - Multi-user: DEEPSEEK_BASE_URL joins the owner-clamped env keys. _configureDeepSeek() forwards the SERVER's own DEEPSEEK_API_KEY into every dsh pane and applyEnvOverrides() lands after it, so a non-granted owner who could redirect the base URL would have the operator's key sent as a bearer credential to a host of their choosing. - Wait registry: until=stop/blocked is refused on docker and remote-SSH dsh sessions (new deepSeekBridgeUnreachable fact in sessionHookOptions). The HERDR triple is set via LOCAL tmux setenv, which crosses neither docker exec nor ssh, so such a session can never post a hook event and the wait burned its whole timeout on every turn. - Approvals: a dsh item is an ALERT, not an answerable card. The answer route refuses (the '1'/Esc keystrokes are Claude-dialog-shaped and the option parser cannot read a third-party TUI's frames, so an answer was a blind keystroke into a foreign composer), and the push notification carries no Approve/Deny actions for dsh sessions. - Status shim (v3): --seq is forwarded and the server drops stale retried reports inside a 60s window (the TUI retries with backoff, so a retried 'working' could land after 'blocked' and resolve an approval whose dialog was still on screen); 4xx responses exit 0 instead of retrying, so one misconfigured session cannot feed the auth rate-limit bucket until the hook endpoint 429s for the whole instance. - Web-UI server: concurrent starts are serialized through a lock (two racing POSTs used to pick the same port and orphan the winner), and the readiness poll / timeout paths only clear or stop the singleton while it is still theirs. First click actually opens the tab now (refreshWebviews, not the nonexistent loadWebviews). DELETE /api/deepseek/web requires the privileged grant in multi-user mode. - Cron: deepseek jobs run the same two-part launch gate as the HTTP create paths (impl moved into the resolver so all three share it) and no longer stamp a Claude default model on the session. - Parity sweeps: quick-start's docker branch rejects deepSeekConfig like the remote branch; the Ralph auto-enable list gained deepseek; HookEventType gained agent_working; the phone overview run menu filters managed webview records like the desktop menu. - install.sh: the dsh identity probe closes stdin (under curl|bash a child that reads stdin eats the rest of the script), bounds the exec with timeout where available, and is memoized to one scan per install. - Welcome screen: .welcome-btn-deepseek styled in the #4d6bfe brand identity (it rendered as an unstyled UA-grey button); stale markup comment about the web shortcut rewritten; clamp docs updated. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
@@ -20,13 +20,13 @@ Implementation detail extracted from `CLAUDE.md` so that file stays small enough
|
||||
|
||||
### External CLI modes (OpenCode, Codex, Gemini, Antigravity, Pi, Grok, DeepSeek)
|
||||
|
||||
**External CLI modes (OpenCode, Codex, Gemini, Antigravity, Pi, Grok, DeepSeek)**: `isExternalCliMode()` in `session.ts` (`mode === 'opencode' || 'codex' || 'gemini' || 'antigravity' || 'pi' || 'grok'`) gates Claude-specific behavior — Ralph tracker, BashToolParser, token/CLI-info parsing, and ❯-prompt readiness detection are all skipped (these CLIs render their own TUIs; readiness = output stabilization instead). All six modes **require tmux — no direct PTY fallback** — because secrets are injected via `tmux setenv` (socket-scoped `${this.tmux()} setenv`, never on the spawn command line): OpenCode gets `OPENCODE_CONFIG_CONTENT` etc., Codex gets `OPENAI_API_KEY`/`CODEX_API_KEY`/`CODEX_HOME` (`setCodexEnvVars`), Gemini gets `GEMINI_API_KEY`/`GOOGLE_API_KEY`/`GOOGLE_CLOUD_PROJECT`/`GOOGLE_APPLICATION_CREDENTIALS`/`GOOGLE_GENAI_USE_VERTEXAI` etc. (`setGeminiEnvVars`, all in `tmux-manager.ts`). Codex specifics: command built by `buildCodexCommand()` (`--model`, `resume <id>`, `--dangerously-bypass-approvals-and-sandbox` from the `codexConfig` payload / `codexDangerouslyBypassApprovals` app setting; `renderMode` is schema-coerced to `'hybrid'`, the only supported mode). Gemini specifics: command built by `buildGeminiCommand()` (`--skip-trust` always, `--approval-mode <default|auto_edit|yolo|plan>` defaulting to `yolo` for parity with Claude's `--dangerously-skip-permissions`, `--model`, `--resume` from the `geminiConfig` payload); availability via `GET /api/gemini/status` — session/quick-start routes fail with `OPERATION_FAILED` + install hint (`npm install -g @google/gemini-cli`) when missing. Codex AND Gemini export `COLORTERM=truecolor` + unset `NO_COLOR` (other modes unset `COLORTERM`); Gemini joins `isAltScreenStripMode()` (Codex/Claude/Gemini are Ink TUIs that repaint inline → strip alt-screen/`3J` so scrollback survives). Codex availability via `GET /api/codex/status`. Antigravity specifics: command built by `buildAntigravityCommand()` (`--model`, `--conversation <id>` resume, `--dangerously-skip-permissions` from the `antigravityConfig` payload); availability via `GET /api/antigravity/status` — routes fail with `OPERATION_FAILED` + install hint (`curl -fsSL https://antigravity.google/cli/install.sh | bash`) when missing. Unlike the other three it is NOT an npm package (standalone binary, `~/.local/bin/agy`), which is why `docker/agent.Dockerfile` installs it with its own `--dir /usr/local/bin` step rather than in the `npm install -g` line, and why it does NOT join `isAltScreenStripMode()`. Frontend: run-mode dropdown → `runCodex()`/`runGemini()` in `session-ui.js` ("Run CX"/"Run GM" labels), App Settings → Agents & CLIs → Codex; Respawn/Ralph options are Claude-only, so session options open on the Session tab for external CLI sessions. ⚠️ `run*()` MUST unwrap the `{success,data}` envelope (`(await res.json()).data.available` / `data.data.sessionId`) — reading the raw shape silently breaks the run. Tests: `test/run-mode-ui.test.ts` + `test/gemini-mode.test.ts` (vm-sandbox harness, no real DOM). Grok specifics: command built by `buildGrokCommand()` (`--always-approve` from `grokConfig.alwaysApprove` — grok's `bypassPermissions` permission mode, deny rules still apply; `--model`; `--resume <id>` / `--continue`, id-regexed so grok's resume-by-TITLE feature can never put an arbitrary string on the spawn line); availability via `GET /api/grok/status`, which carries `version` because the resolver version-probes candidates (`grok` has npm squatters, e.g. @vibe-kit/grok-cli — `GROK_VERSION_REGEX` is shared with the dependency registry so doctor and run mode agree). Like antigravity it is a standalone binary (xAI installer → `~/.grok/bin`, symlinked into `~/.local/bin`), so `docker/agent.Dockerfile` installs it in its own step (copy to `/usr/local/bin`, drop root's `~/.grok` in the same layer) and it stays OUT of `isAltScreenStripMode()` (fullscreen alt-screen TUI with mouse support — the opencode case, not the Ink case). Env allowlist: `GROK_*` plus the vendor namespace `XAI_*` (`XAI_API_KEY` is grok's documented headless auth var — the same narrow-vendor-namespace reasoning as `GOOGLE_*` for gemini). Docker cred seeding is per-file (`auth.json`, `config.toml`, `pager.toml` from `~/.grok` — the dir also holds `sessions/`, `memory/`, and the ~160MB binary under `downloads/`). Grok tests: `test/grok-mode.test.ts`, `test/grok-cli-resolver.test.ts`.
|
||||
**External CLI modes (OpenCode, Codex, Gemini, Antigravity, Pi, Grok, DeepSeek)**: `isExternalCliMode()` in `session.ts` (`mode === 'opencode' || 'codex' || 'gemini' || 'antigravity' || 'pi' || 'grok' || 'deepseek'`) gates Claude-specific behavior — Ralph tracker, BashToolParser, token/CLI-info parsing, and ❯-prompt readiness detection are all skipped (these CLIs render their own TUIs; readiness = output stabilization instead). All seven modes **require tmux — no direct PTY fallback** — because secrets are injected via `tmux setenv` (socket-scoped `${this.tmux()} setenv`, never on the spawn command line): OpenCode gets `OPENCODE_CONFIG_CONTENT` etc., Codex gets `OPENAI_API_KEY`/`CODEX_API_KEY`/`CODEX_HOME` (`setCodexEnvVars`), Gemini gets `GEMINI_API_KEY`/`GOOGLE_API_KEY`/`GOOGLE_CLOUD_PROJECT`/`GOOGLE_APPLICATION_CREDENTIALS`/`GOOGLE_GENAI_USE_VERTEXAI` etc. (`setGeminiEnvVars`, all in `tmux-manager.ts`). Codex specifics: command built by `buildCodexCommand()` (`--model`, `resume <id>`, `--dangerously-bypass-approvals-and-sandbox` from the `codexConfig` payload / `codexDangerouslyBypassApprovals` app setting; `renderMode` is schema-coerced to `'hybrid'`, the only supported mode). Gemini specifics: command built by `buildGeminiCommand()` (`--skip-trust` always, `--approval-mode <default|auto_edit|yolo|plan>` defaulting to `yolo` for parity with Claude's `--dangerously-skip-permissions`, `--model`, `--resume` from the `geminiConfig` payload); availability via `GET /api/gemini/status` — session/quick-start routes fail with `OPERATION_FAILED` + install hint (`npm install -g @google/gemini-cli`) when missing. Codex AND Gemini export `COLORTERM=truecolor` + unset `NO_COLOR` (other modes unset `COLORTERM`); Gemini joins `isAltScreenStripMode()` (Codex/Claude/Gemini are Ink TUIs that repaint inline → strip alt-screen/`3J` so scrollback survives). Codex availability via `GET /api/codex/status`. Antigravity specifics: command built by `buildAntigravityCommand()` (`--model`, `--conversation <id>` resume, `--dangerously-skip-permissions` from the `antigravityConfig` payload); availability via `GET /api/antigravity/status` — routes fail with `OPERATION_FAILED` + install hint (`curl -fsSL https://antigravity.google/cli/install.sh | bash`) when missing. Unlike the other three it is NOT an npm package (standalone binary, `~/.local/bin/agy`), which is why `docker/agent.Dockerfile` installs it with its own `--dir /usr/local/bin` step rather than in the `npm install -g` line, and why it does NOT join `isAltScreenStripMode()`. Frontend: run-mode dropdown → `runCodex()`/`runGemini()` in `session-ui.js` ("Run CX"/"Run GM" labels), App Settings → Agents & CLIs → Codex; Respawn/Ralph options are Claude-only, so session options open on the Session tab for external CLI sessions. ⚠️ `run*()` MUST unwrap the `{success,data}` envelope (`(await res.json()).data.available` / `data.data.sessionId`) — reading the raw shape silently breaks the run. Tests: `test/run-mode-ui.test.ts` + `test/gemini-mode.test.ts` (vm-sandbox harness, no real DOM). Grok specifics: command built by `buildGrokCommand()` (`--always-approve` from `grokConfig.alwaysApprove` — grok's `bypassPermissions` permission mode, deny rules still apply; `--model`; `--resume <id>` / `--continue`, id-regexed so grok's resume-by-TITLE feature can never put an arbitrary string on the spawn line); availability via `GET /api/grok/status`, which carries `version` because the resolver version-probes candidates (`grok` has npm squatters, e.g. @vibe-kit/grok-cli — `GROK_VERSION_REGEX` is shared with the dependency registry so doctor and run mode agree). Like antigravity it is a standalone binary (xAI installer → `~/.grok/bin`, symlinked into `~/.local/bin`), so `docker/agent.Dockerfile` installs it in its own step (copy to `/usr/local/bin`, drop root's `~/.grok` in the same layer) and it stays OUT of `isAltScreenStripMode()` (fullscreen alt-screen TUI with mouse support — the opencode case, not the Ink case). Env allowlist: `GROK_*` plus the vendor namespace `XAI_*` (`XAI_API_KEY` is grok's documented headless auth var — the same narrow-vendor-namespace reasoning as `GOOGLE_*` for gemini). Docker cred seeding is per-file (`auth.json`, `config.toml`, `pager.toml` from `~/.grok` — the dir also holds `sessions/`, `memory/`, and the ~160MB binary under `downloads/`). Grok tests: `test/grok-mode.test.ts`, `test/grok-cli-resolver.test.ts`.
|
||||
|
||||
**DeepSeek Harness (`dsh`) specifics** — the mode that breaks three of the assumptions the six above share, so read this before changing anything about it.
|
||||
|
||||
⚠️ **The agent is a PROFILE, not the binary.** `dsh` is a launcher over `$DSH_HOME/profiles/<name>` (an ordered stack of plugin-bundle patch layers), and DeepSeek ships only `web` (browser UI), `headless` (one-shot) and `base` (no app). The interactive terminal front door is ALWAYS third-party. So availability is TWO questions, not one, and `isDeepSeekRunnable()` (binary AND a pane-capable profile) is what the Run button gates on while `isDeepSeekAvailable()` (binary only) gates the "add a profile" affordance and the web-UI shortcut. Reporting only the binary would let Run spawn a pane that dies on arrival, which is this mode's single most confusing failure. `buildDeepSeekCommand()` emits `dsh --profile <name> [--resume [id]]`; an absent profile resolves through `resolveDefaultDeepSeekProfile()`, which prefers a recognized TUI, then an UNRECOGNIZED profile (third-party by construction — a classifier that has not heard of a bundle must not hide it), and refuses `web`/`headless`, which cannot drive a pane.
|
||||
|
||||
⚠️ **The permission switch is an ENV VAR, not a flag.** The harness has no `--dangerously-skip-permissions` equivalent; its sandbox/approval rows read `DSH_PERMISSION_MODE` with three presets (`read-only` / `workspace-write` / `danger-full-access`; measured from `dsh --dump-default-config`). It is exported via `tmux setenv` in `_configureDeepSeek()`, never on the command line, and `test/deepseek-mode.test.ts` pins that nothing permission-shaped ever reaches the spawn line. This is the ONE place a Codeman env export is the right mechanism rather than the forbidden one: unlike `CLAUDE_CODE_EFFORT_LEVEL` (which hard-locks in-session `/effort`), the harness reads it with `??` as a boot-time DEFAULT, so it stays soft. Absent = `workspace-write`, which still asks, so the multi-user clamp is the only-if-sent branch (codex/antigravity/grok shape, not pi's materialize) — and it clamps down to `workspace-write`, NOT `read-only`, because the clamp removes privilege without breaking a session's ability to edit its own workspace. ⚠️ **Clamping the config is only HALF the gate here, and this is the only CLI where that is true.** Every sibling's bypass is a command-line flag, reachable only through the per-CLI config `clampExternalCliBypassForOwner()` already owns. DeepSeek's is an env var, `DSH_*` is an allowlisted `envOverrides` prefix (it must be — that is also how the harness's ordinary knobs are set), and `applyEnvOverrides()` runs AFTER `_configureDeepSeek()` in tmux-manager, so `envOverrides: {DSH_PERMISSION_MODE: 'danger-full-access'}` sent on the SAME request as a clamped config lands last and wins. `clampEnvOverridesForOwner()` (session-routes.ts, exported as `_clampEnvOverridesForOwner` for tests) DROPS `DSH_PERMISSION_MODE` and `DSH_HOME` for a non-granted owner rather than rewriting them, since dropping falls through to what `_configureDeepSeek()` exports, which is already the clamped value. `DSH_HOME` is on that list because it aims the launcher at a profile tree and a profile's plugin code executes at BOOT, before any approval row can apply — the wider of the two holes. No-op in single-user mode and for a granted owner, like every other clamp.
|
||||
⚠️ **The permission switch is an ENV VAR, not a flag.** The harness has no `--dangerously-skip-permissions` equivalent; its sandbox/approval rows read `DSH_PERMISSION_MODE` with three presets (`read-only` / `workspace-write` / `danger-full-access`; measured from `dsh --dump-default-config`). It is exported via `tmux setenv` in `_configureDeepSeek()`, never on the command line, and `test/deepseek-mode.test.ts` pins that nothing permission-shaped ever reaches the spawn line. This is the ONE place a Codeman env export is the right mechanism rather than the forbidden one: unlike `CLAUDE_CODE_EFFORT_LEVEL` (which hard-locks in-session `/effort`), the harness reads it with `??` as a boot-time DEFAULT, so it stays soft. Absent = `workspace-write`, which still asks, so the multi-user clamp is the only-if-sent branch (codex/antigravity/grok shape, not pi's materialize) — and it clamps down to `workspace-write`, NOT `read-only`, because the clamp removes privilege without breaking a session's ability to edit its own workspace. ⚠️ **Clamping the config is only HALF the gate here, and this is the only CLI where that is true.** Every sibling's bypass is a command-line flag, reachable only through the per-CLI config `clampExternalCliBypassForOwner()` already owns. DeepSeek's is an env var, `DSH_*` is an allowlisted `envOverrides` prefix (it must be — that is also how the harness's ordinary knobs are set), and `applyEnvOverrides()` runs AFTER `_configureDeepSeek()` in tmux-manager, so `envOverrides: {DSH_PERMISSION_MODE: 'danger-full-access'}` sent on the SAME request as a clamped config lands last and wins. `clampEnvOverridesForOwner()` (session-routes.ts, exported as `_clampEnvOverridesForOwner` for tests) DROPS `DSH_PERMISSION_MODE`, `DSH_HOME` and `DEEPSEEK_BASE_URL` for a non-granted owner (the last because `_configureDeepSeek()` forwards the SERVER's own `DEEPSEEK_API_KEY` into the pane, so a redirected base URL would send it to a foreign host) rather than rewriting them, since dropping falls through to what `_configureDeepSeek()` exports, which is already the clamped value. `DSH_HOME` is on that list because it aims the launcher at a profile tree and a profile's plugin code executes at BOOT, before any approval row can apply — the wider of the two holes. No-op in single-user mode and for a granted owner, like every other clamp.
|
||||
|
||||
⚠️ **It is the only non-claude mode that passes `hooksAvailableForMode()`, and it earned that.** The community terminal front door reports its own lifecycle to a supervising process through a generic env-var-gated contract inherited from Herdr: with `HERDR_ENV=1` + `HERDR_BIN_PATH` + `HERDR_PANE_ID` set it shells out `<bin> pane report-agent <paneId> --state idle|working|blocked …` on every state change and treats exit 0 as delivered. `deepseek-status-shim.ts` GENERATES a small script into the data dir (like `self-update-runner.sh`, so npm installs and git clones behave alike) and points `HERDR_BIN_PATH` at it; it forwards to `POST /api/hook-event` as `idle→stop`, `blocked→permission_prompt`, `working→agent_working`. So a dsh session gets real respawn triggers, real `wait` stop/blocked signals and real Approvals Inbox items instead of output-stabilization guesswork. This is an interface implementation, not an impersonation — no real `herdr` binary is ever executed. A TUI that does not implement the contract simply never calls the shim and falls back to stabilization, so the feature is inert rather than harmful there. ⚠️ **For deepseek alone, `hooksAvailableForMode()` is a per-SESSION question**, which is why it takes a `HookCapabilityOptions` second argument and every call site passes `sessionHookOptions(session)`: `deepSeekConfig.statusReporting: false` skips the `HERDR_*` export, and that triple is the only reason a dsh session posts anything, so answering from the mode alone would accept `until=stop` on a session where nothing can ever send one — the infinite-wait-dressed-as-a-timeout the predicate exists to prevent. The option defaults permissive (`!== false`), so a call site that forgets it degrades to the old behaviour instead of 400ing a working session. ⚠️ Profile conformance is the LIMIT of what is knowable at request time: `resolveDefaultDeepSeekProfile()` deliberately treats an unrecognized profile as launchable, so a non-conforming TUI still answers true and still times out on an explicit `stop` — which is why the DEFAULT signal set keeps `idle`/`exit`. ⚠️ **The predicate is not a stand-in for "is this a claude session"**, though it read like one while `claude` was the only true answer: Read My Mind (`POST /api/sessions/:id/readmymind`) and intent capture (`captureIntentPrompt`) read Claude's own transcript and were silently widened to deepseek by this change, so both compare `mode === 'claude'` directly and a static check in `test/deepseek-mode.test.ts` keeps them there.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user