mirror of
https://github.com/Ark0N/Codeman.git
synced 2026-10-08 16:39:42 +02:00
fix(remote): a proxied host is reachability-unknown; scope remote: SSE per session
Review round 2 on #439. 1. The bare TCP probe connects to host:port, which a host behind a jump host or SOCKS proxy does not answer even while ssh works. Acting on that verdict drew a permanent banner over a healthy session, replaced a real "needs tmux" error with "not reachable" in quick-start, and - with a wake target - buffered every HTTP input for the life of the session, since the readiness poll could never succeed. `WakeableRemote` now carries `jumpHost`/`socksProxy`/`extraSshOptions`, and `isProbeable()` turns such a host into reachability-UNKNOWN: input is delivered, `checkReachable` / `checkHostReachable` answer `null` (never `false`), `ensureHostAwake` returns `'unprobeable'` (handled like `'no-target'`), the quick-start gate fires on `=== false` only, and `GET …/reachability` reports `reachable: null, probeable: false` so the banner has nothing to key on. A wake target can still be fired for it, blind: no readiness poll, no reattach, no toast - the response says only whether the packet went out. 2. `'remote:'` joins the session-scoped SSE prefixes. The create/attach wake has no session yet, so the registry names the requesting user (`ensureHostAwake({ requestedBy })` -> `username` in the payload) and `deriveSseHint` routes on it; with neither it fails closed to admins. Single-user mode is unaffected. Smaller, from the same review: - A flush write that fails now drops the remaining buffer (logged) instead of retaining it: the wake still resolved and marked the host reachable, so the retained chunk waited for the NEXT wake and was replayed hours later, after everything typed since. Same policy as the oversized paste. - The banner polls on tab activation (a user action) and on its 30 s timer only for a host with a wake target; a timer connecting to a host Codeman cannot wake is the traffic invariant #2 rejects keepalives for. A proxied host is never polled. - `probeRemoteHostReachable`, `runRemoteWakeCommand` and the default UDP socket refuse under VITEST, as remote-files.ts does. The guard caught a leak on the spot: `createDefaultRemoteWakeDeps({ probe })` overrode the probe but still polled readiness with the real one, so the shutdown test had been connecting to a production address. The poll now uses the injected probe. - docs/remote-sessions.md is additions only again (the reformatting is gone); the architecture-invariants overlap resolved itself in the merge. Live, against a throwaway instance with a non-routable ghost host: proxied -> no probe, no wake, the genuine ssh error after 10 s; direct (control) -> probe, magic packet, "did not come back" after the 40 s budget. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01QdGP4jUTjc9J2RYYykDrCG
This commit is contained in:
co-authored by
Claude Opus 5
parent
e271a65e79
commit
1040f6c489
@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ Model is NOT a session field: it is a composition entry in the profile's config
|
||||
|
||||
### Remote SSH cases
|
||||
|
||||
**Remote host wake-on-LAN from user input**: an optional `RemoteHost.wakeMac` (magic packet built and broadcast by Codeman) or `RemoteHost.wakeCommand` (a single executable path, run WITHOUT a shell, and the explicit override) lets the input route — and an explicit `POST /api/sessions/:id/wake` — wake a SLEEPING host instead of writing into a stalled ssh pane; `tmux send-keys` succeeds against a stalled pane, so the bytes used to vanish silently. The wake flow lives in `src/remote-wake.ts` and is reachable **only** from an EXPLICIT user request: `POST /api/sessions/:id/input`, that explicit wake route, and the create/attach path (`POST /api/quick-start` for a remote case, `POST /api/sessions` with `attachRemoteSession`, via `ensureHostAwake`), because "the user pressed Run on a sleeping host" is the same kind of request and the tmux probe would otherwise fail with a misleading "needs tmux installed". Everything TIMER-driven must never wake a host: the COD-108 auto-reconnect watcher, `Server.handleRemoteSessionDropped` and boot recovery have no access to the registry, or a host would be re-woken seconds after each suspend and could never stay asleep (asserted by wiring guards in `test/remote-wake.test.ts`, not just documented — including that `ensureHostAwake` is called from the HTTP route only, since `cron-service.ts` builds sessions through the shared service with nobody waiting on the answer). `GET /api/sessions/:id/reachability` only ASKS — it never wakes — and feeds the amber "host unreachable" banner (`host-wake-ui.js`) whose action is either Wake or, with no target configured, "Configure WoL" → `#wakeConfigModal` (saved via `PUT /api/remote-hosts/:id`). Detection is a throttled bare TCP probe (no ssh, no `ServerAliveInterval` — keepalives would move bytes into an idle connection every interval), input is buffered and flushed in order after `reattachRemote()` (the send-and-wait path blocks instead, as does the create path, with a shorter request budget), and the wake fields are re-read from `remote-hosts.json` on recovery AND (throttled, cached) live for a running session, because the persisted `remote` snapshot would never see a field added later (`rehydrateRemoteHostFields` + `RemoteWakeDeps.resolveRemote`). Design + invariants: `docs/remote-sessions.md` §Wake-on-LAN from user input.
|
||||
**Remote host wake-on-LAN from user input**: an optional `RemoteHost.wakeMac` (magic packet built and broadcast by Codeman) or `RemoteHost.wakeCommand` (a single executable path, run WITHOUT a shell, and the explicit override) lets the input route — and an explicit `POST /api/sessions/:id/wake` — wake a SLEEPING host instead of writing into a stalled ssh pane; `tmux send-keys` succeeds against a stalled pane, so the bytes used to vanish silently. The wake flow lives in `src/remote-wake.ts` and is reachable **only** from an EXPLICIT user request: `POST /api/sessions/:id/input`, that explicit wake route, and the create/attach path (`POST /api/quick-start` for a remote case, `POST /api/sessions` with `attachRemoteSession`, via `ensureHostAwake`), because "the user pressed Run on a sleeping host" is the same kind of request and the tmux probe would otherwise fail with a misleading "needs tmux installed". Everything TIMER-driven must never wake a host: the COD-108 auto-reconnect watcher, `Server.handleRemoteSessionDropped` and boot recovery have no access to the registry, or a host would be re-woken seconds after each suspend and could never stay asleep (asserted by wiring guards in `test/remote-wake.test.ts`, not just documented — including that `ensureHostAwake` is called from the HTTP route only, since `cron-service.ts` builds sessions through the shared service with nobody waiting on the answer). `GET /api/sessions/:id/reachability` only ASKS — it never wakes — and feeds the amber "host unreachable" banner (`host-wake-ui.js`) whose action is either Wake or, with no target configured, "Configure WoL" → `#wakeConfigModal` (saved via `PUT /api/remote-hosts/:id`). Detection is a throttled bare TCP probe (no ssh, no `ServerAliveInterval` — keepalives would move bytes into an idle connection every interval; and a host behind a jump host/SOCKS proxy is reachability-UNKNOWN, never "asleep": `isProbeable()` keeps the registry from buffering, gating or bannering on a probe that cannot reach it), input is buffered and flushed in order after `reattachRemote()` (the send-and-wait path blocks instead, as does the create path, with a shorter request budget), and the wake fields are re-read from `remote-hosts.json` on recovery AND (throttled, cached) live for a running session, because the persisted `remote` snapshot would never see a field added later (`rehydrateRemoteHostFields` + `RemoteWakeDeps.resolveRemote`). Design + invariants: `docs/remote-sessions.md` §Wake-on-LAN from user input.
|
||||
|
||||
**Remote SSH cases** (COD-94/#145): cases can point at a **remote host** (`~/.codeman/remote-hosts.json` + `remote-cases.json` via `src/remote-hosts.ts`; CRUD under `/api/cases` — cases route file). A remote session launches a LOCAL tmux pane running `ssh <host>` that creates a durable REMOTE tmux session on a **dedicated socket** `-L codeman-remote` with name `codeman-ssh-<id>` — deliberately failing the remote Codeman's `SAFE_MUX_NAME_PATTERN` so a Codeman instance on the target host never adopts it; no `-g` global tmux options are set remotely. `remotePath`/`identityFile` are schema-guarded against shell injection (backticks/`$` rejected — same approach as `extraSshOptions`); remote tmux availability is probed via `checkRemoteTmuxAvailable()` in quick-start (ssh args carry `-o ConnectTimeout=10`). Remote claude defaults to an idempotent `claude --session-id <id> || claude --resume <id>` pair under a login shell, so a respawn or reattach continues the SAME conversation rather than starting a fresh one (remote omp gets the same treatment via `--continue`; ⚠️ because the claude arm is an `a || b` pair under `-c`, that pane's PID is the login shell, not the agent); per-host `commands.*` override. Session kill best-effort kills the remote tmux too. `SessionState.remote`/`MuxSession.remote` round-trip through recovery (`restoreMuxSessions` passes `remote` back into the Session constructor). ⚠️ Run flows must route remote cases through `POST /api/quick-start` (which resolves the remote case and skips LOCAL CLI availability gates) — `POST /api/sessions` stat-validates `workingDir` locally and has no `caseName`. `envOverrides`/`effort`/`modelOverride`/`codexConfig`/`geminiConfig` are rejected for remote quick-starts (not silently dropped). UI: Create Case modal → Remote tab. Tests: `test/remote-hosts.test.ts`, `test/remote-ssh-options.test.ts`. ⚠️ **Reading a file in a remote case goes over ssh too** (#415): `src/remote-files.ts` is the single remote-READ layer (`buildRemoteFileCommand` = `buildSshConnectionArgs` + one shellescaped remote command; `remoteProbePaths` returns remote realpath + stat; `remoteCreateReadStream` streams a `Range` via `tail -c +N | head -c L` and its `close()` must be wired to the response's `close` or the ssh child outlives an aborted download). The guard order matches the local path exactly (`validateSessionFilePathLexical` → remote realpath of BOTH file and workspace root → containment → sensitive-path → size cap on the REMOTE size), a request path arrives from the browser and is only ever interpolated as a `shellescape`d token, and an unreachable host answers **502**, never a 404. ⚠️ The probe's symlink resolution FAILS CLOSED: `readlink -f` where it exists, otherwise a `cd -P`/`pwd -P` directory walk plus a bounded plain-`readlink` loop over the last component, and anything it cannot fully resolve is reported unresolvable (404), never as the unresolved string — the first version resolved the directory chain only, so on a host without `readlink -f` a `ws/notes.txt -> ~/.ssh/id_rsa` link passed containment under its own path while `cat` served the key. Records are NUL-separated and index-keyed so a newline in a filename cannot shift the mapping. ⚠️ ssh children are BOUNDED: probes and buffered reads go through `src/remote-ssh-limiter.ts` (a `document-conversion-limiter`-shaped semaphore, default 4), the attachment-history list probes its whole history in ONE batched call (`probeRemoteAttachmentHistory`, threaded into `registerExternalAttachment({remoteProbes})`), and probes chunk at 40 paths — a prompt-injected agent printing `codeman://attach` links in a remote session used to fork one `ssh` per link. `describeExecError` never returns Node's `Command failed: <ssh line>` message (identity path + probe script in a 502 body). The `PUT /file-content` guard sits AHEAD of `validateSessionFilePath`, which resolves LOCALLY, or a same-named local directory (an sshfs mount) takes the write. Under `VITEST` the three IO functions refuse rather than connect. This covers the ATTACHMENT routes too, which is the half a clicked path needs when the file is OUTSIDE the case directory (`_isExternalPreviewPath` sends it to `POST …/attachments`): registration, by-id `raw`, metadata and the history list all resolve over ssh (`registerExternalAttachment({remote})`, `resolveServableRemoteAttachment`), and what decides the host is the SESSION, never the path string — the same absolute path means a different file on each host. Deliberately NOT supported over ssh: writes (`edit=1`/`PUT` answer 400, `editable` is always false), office previews/thumbnails, the file tree/picker, `tail-file`. Tests: `test/remote-files.test.ts`, `test/routes/file-routes-remote.test.ts`.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user