fix(remote): a proxied host is reachability-unknown; scope remote: SSE per session

Review round 2 on #439.

1. The bare TCP probe connects to host:port, which a host behind a jump host
   or SOCKS proxy does not answer even while ssh works. Acting on that
   verdict drew a permanent banner over a healthy session, replaced a real
   "needs tmux" error with "not reachable" in quick-start, and - with a wake
   target - buffered every HTTP input for the life of the session, since the
   readiness poll could never succeed. `WakeableRemote` now carries
   `jumpHost`/`socksProxy`/`extraSshOptions`, and `isProbeable()` turns such
   a host into reachability-UNKNOWN: input is delivered, `checkReachable` /
   `checkHostReachable` answer `null` (never `false`), `ensureHostAwake`
   returns `'unprobeable'` (handled like `'no-target'`), the quick-start gate
   fires on `=== false` only, and `GET …/reachability` reports
   `reachable: null, probeable: false` so the banner has nothing to key on.
   A wake target can still be fired for it, blind: no readiness poll, no
   reattach, no toast - the response says only whether the packet went out.

2. `'remote:'` joins the session-scoped SSE prefixes. The create/attach wake
   has no session yet, so the registry names the requesting user
   (`ensureHostAwake({ requestedBy })` -> `username` in the payload) and
   `deriveSseHint` routes on it; with neither it fails closed to admins.
   Single-user mode is unaffected.

Smaller, from the same review:

- A flush write that fails now drops the remaining buffer (logged) instead
  of retaining it: the wake still resolved and marked the host reachable, so
  the retained chunk waited for the NEXT wake and was replayed hours later,
  after everything typed since. Same policy as the oversized paste.
- The banner polls on tab activation (a user action) and on its 30 s timer
  only for a host with a wake target; a timer connecting to a host Codeman
  cannot wake is the traffic invariant #2 rejects keepalives for. A proxied
  host is never polled.
- `probeRemoteHostReachable`, `runRemoteWakeCommand` and the default UDP
  socket refuse under VITEST, as remote-files.ts does. The guard caught a
  leak on the spot: `createDefaultRemoteWakeDeps({ probe })` overrode the
  probe but still polled readiness with the real one, so the shutdown test
  had been connecting to a production address. The poll now uses the
  injected probe.
- docs/remote-sessions.md is additions only again (the reformatting is
  gone); the architecture-invariants overlap resolved itself in the merge.

Live, against a throwaway instance with a non-routable ghost host: proxied
-> no probe, no wake, the genuine ssh error after 10 s; direct (control) ->
probe, magic packet, "did not come back" after the 40 s budget.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01QdGP4jUTjc9J2RYYykDrCG
This commit is contained in:
Randalix
2026-09-18 22:46:11 +02:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5
parent e271a65e79
commit 1040f6c489
12 changed files with 609 additions and 83 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -217,7 +217,7 @@ Codeman is a Claude Code session manager with web interface and autonomous Ralph
**Remote sessions + remote SSH cases**: a case can point at a remote host. The agent runs inside a durable remote `tmux -L codeman-remote` (session name `codeman-ssh-<id>`, deliberately failing the remote Codeman's `SAFE_MUX_NAME_PATTERN` so an instance on the target host never adopts it), fronted by a LOCAL tmux pane running `ssh`. Attached (`owned:false`) sessions **detach, never kill** on tab close; owned ones propagate `kill-session`. A bounded-backoff watcher auto-reconnects dropped sessions (`remoteAutoReconnect`, default ON). ⚠️ **It revives ONLY when the durable remote tmux session is verifiably still alive** (`remoteTmuxSessionAlive()`, a `has-session` probe over ssh, #355): a clean agent exit (Ctrl-C, Ctrl-D, `exit`) tears that session down, and `isPaneDead()` cannot tell it from a transport drop, so the watcher used to relaunch a FRESH agent after every clean exit (claude only looked fine because its `|| --resume` fallback masked it). An unreachable host answers `undefined`, which also means do not revive. ⚠️ `has-session` prints NOTHING on success, so the probe is classified by EXIT STATUS (`classifyRemoteAliveExit`: 0 alive, ssh's 255 or a timeout unknown, anything else gone); reading stdout classified every live session as gone and silently disabled transport-drop reconnects. The answer is cached per session and forgotten whenever the pane is seen alive again, or a stale `true` from one transport drop would revive the next clean exit. ⚠️ **File reads in a remote case are the second ssh surface** (#415, `src/remote-files.ts`): they go through `buildSshConnectionArgs()` as well, a browser-supplied path is only ever a `shellescape`d token, an unreachable host answers 502 (never 404), the size cap uses the REMOTE size, and no remote file is ever copied onto the server's disk — which is why writes, office previews and thumbnails are deliberately unsupported over ssh (the `PUT` guard sits BEFORE the local path validation, or a same-named local directory such as an sshfs mount takes the write). The probe's symlink resolution FAILS CLOSED (a path it cannot canonicalize is a 404, never its own unresolved string: the directory-only fallback let a `notes.txt -> ~/.ssh/id_rsa` link pass containment), and ssh children are BOUNDED by `src/remote-ssh-limiter.ts` plus one batched probe per attachment-history listing, because terminal output in a remote session is written on the remote host and a prompt-injected agent can print hundreds of `codeman://attach` links. The ATTACHMENT routes (a clicked path outside the case dir) go through the same layer, and which host a record is read from follows the SESSION, never the path string. ⚠️ **Command-injection surface: every ssh command line must flow through `buildSshConnectionArgs()`**, which `shellescape`s every user field. Never hand-build an ssh line elsewhere. ⚠️ Run flows must route remote cases through `POST /api/quick-start`, not `POST /api/sessions` (which stat-validates `workingDir` locally and has no `caseName`). → [architecture-invariants#remote-sessions-over-ssh](docs/architecture-invariants.md#remote-sessions-over-ssh), [#remote-ssh-cases](docs/architecture-invariants.md#remote-ssh-cases), `docs/remote-sessions.md`
**Wake-on-LAN (`remote-wake.ts`)**: an optional `RemoteHost.wakeMac` (Codeman builds the magic packet itself) or `RemoteHost.wakeCommand` (single executable path, run without a shell, takes precedence) lets the INPUT route, `POST /api/sessions/:id/wake`, and the user's own create/attach request (`POST /api/quick-start`, `POST /api/sessions` with `attachRemoteSession`, via `ensureHostAwake`) wake a sleeping host instead of writing into a stalled ssh pane. ⚠️ An explicit request — input, the wake button, or the user pressing Run/Attach — and NOTHING else may wake: the auto-reconnect watcher, `handleRemoteSessionDropped`, boot recovery and `cron-service.ts` have no access to the registry (a wake there would re-wake the host seconds after every suspend, and the create wake is wired in the route rather than the shared session service for exactly that reason), which `test/remote-wake.test.ts` asserts as two wiring guards — the second also pins that `server.ts` holds the registry for its LIFETIME only (`drop` on cleanup, `stop` on shutdown) and never calls a waking method. `GET /api/sessions/:id/reachability` merely probes and never wakes. Detection is a throttled bare TCP probe — deliberately no `ServerAliveInterval`, because keepalives move bytes into an idle connection every interval and that is what a byte-threshold idle detector must not read as activity. Input arriving during a wake is buffered (a chunk over 4 KB is dropped whole, never delivered as a fragment) and flushed in order after `reattachRemote()`; send-and-wait blocks instead. ⚠️ Browser keystrokes travel over the WebSocket, which deliberately does NOT pass through the registry (that is the hot path), so only the HTTP input path ever queues anything — the banner must not promise queued input for the Wake button. A request that waits on the wake (create/attach, and the button) uses the 40 s `REMOTE_WAKE_REQUEST_READY_TIMEOUT_MS`, not the 90 s session default, because the dashboard's reverse proxy cuts a request at its own 60 s `proxy_read_timeout`. The wake fields are re-read from `remote-hosts.json` on recovery and, throttled+cached via `RemoteWakeDeps.resolveRemote`, for a LIVE session, since the persisted `remote` snapshot never sees a field added later. UI: the amber `#hostWakeBanner` (`host-wake-ui.js`) with Wake / "Configure WoL" → `#wakeConfigModal`.
**Wake-on-LAN (`remote-wake.ts`)**: an optional `RemoteHost.wakeMac` (Codeman builds the magic packet itself) or `RemoteHost.wakeCommand` (single executable path, run without a shell, takes precedence) lets the INPUT route, `POST /api/sessions/:id/wake`, and the user's own create/attach request (`POST /api/quick-start`, `POST /api/sessions` with `attachRemoteSession`, via `ensureHostAwake`) wake a sleeping host instead of writing into a stalled ssh pane. ⚠️ An explicit request — input, the wake button, or the user pressing Run/Attach — and NOTHING else may wake: the auto-reconnect watcher, `handleRemoteSessionDropped`, boot recovery and `cron-service.ts` have no access to the registry (a wake there would re-wake the host seconds after every suspend, and the create wake is wired in the route rather than the shared session service for exactly that reason), which `test/remote-wake.test.ts` asserts as two wiring guards — the second also pins that `server.ts` holds the registry for its LIFETIME only (`drop` on cleanup, `stop` on shutdown) and never calls a waking method. `GET /api/sessions/:id/reachability` merely probes and never wakes. Detection is a throttled bare TCP probe — deliberately no `ServerAliveInterval`, because keepalives move bytes into an idle connection every interval and that is what a byte-threshold idle detector must not read as activity. ⚠️ A host behind `jumpHost`/`socksProxy`/a `ProxyCommand` option is reachability-UNKNOWN (`isProbeable()`): the probe connects to `host:port`, which such a host does not answer even while ssh works, so the registry never buffers for it, never gates create/attach on it (`'unprobeable'`), and `/reachability` answers `reachable: null, probeable: false` — the banner keys on a PROVEN `false`, and the banner's 30 s poller runs only for a host with a wake target (a timer connecting to a host Codeman cannot wake is the same timer-driven traffic the keepalive rule forbids). Input arriving during a wake is buffered (a chunk over 4 KB is dropped whole, never delivered as a fragment) and flushed in order after `reattachRemote()` — a flush write that fails drops the rest (logged) rather than retaining it for a wake hours later; send-and-wait blocks instead. ⚠️ Browser keystrokes travel over the WebSocket, which deliberately does NOT pass through the registry (that is the hot path), so only the HTTP input path ever queues anything — the banner must not promise queued input for the Wake button. A request that waits on the wake (create/attach, and the button) uses the 40 s `REMOTE_WAKE_REQUEST_READY_TIMEOUT_MS`, not the 90 s session default, because the dashboard's reverse proxy cuts a request at its own 60 s `proxy_read_timeout`. The wake fields are re-read from `remote-hosts.json` on recovery and, throttled+cached via `RemoteWakeDeps.resolveRemote`, for a LIVE session, since the persisted `remote` snapshot never sees a field added later. UI: the amber `#hostWakeBanner` (`host-wake-ui.js`) with Wake / "Configure WoL" → `#wakeConfigModal`. The `remote:` SSE family is session-scoped in multi-user mode; a create/attach wake names its requester (`username`) since it has no session yet. `remote-wake.ts` refuses real IO under `VITEST` like `remote-files.ts`.
**Docker cases**: a case can point at a **container**, with any of the CLI run modes running inside it. Like remote-SSH this is a **LOCATION OVERLAY on cases, never a `SessionMode` of its own**. Exactly one long-lived container **per case**, shared by all its sessions, so killing a session kills only that session's in-container tmux and **never** `docker stop` while siblings remain. The workspace is a real host dir bind-mounted at the **same absolute path**, which is what keeps file-routes/watchers on real host bytes and makes the in-container transcript projHash match the host. Credentials are **seeded** (RO mount, copied into the container once) rather than shared RW, so in-container CLIs never write refreshed tokens back to the host, and bind mounts are excluded from `docker commit` so exports stay secret-free. **NEVER a create-time `-e` for secrets, NEVER `--privileged`, NEVER the docker socket.** Config drift is detected via a label hash and a drifted launch is REFUSED rather than silently launched with stale config. ⚠️ A case may instead **ADOPT** a container the user already runs (`DockerCase.owned === false`, mirror of remote-SSH's `owned:false`): Codeman only `exec`s into it and never creates, starts, stops, restarts or removes it, so a missing or stopped container FAILS CLOSED with an actionable message instead of being fixed. Absent = owned, so existing cases are byte-identical. ⚠️ An ADOPTED container may back SEVERAL cases at different in-container directories (`classifyAdoptContainerConflict` in `docker-hosts.ts`: an exact twin on the same container AND directory is refused, an owned container still backs exactly one case, and a container another user adopted is refused), which is what the Add Case panel's "copy an existing case" picker relies on; the wire carries `CaseInfo.docker.owned` ONLY when false, so the picker tests `=== false`, never truthiness. The guarantee is enforced at four independent layers because it cannot be observed by using the feature: `buildDockerStopCommand`/`buildDockerRemoveCommand` throw during pure STRING CONSTRUCTION, `removeDockerContainer` refuses again, drift reports "none" (an adopted container carries no `codeman.confighash` label, so a real comparison would 409 the launch forever), and the boot reaper skips it. ⚠️ Two lifecycle touches the original design missed and that are easy to re-introduce: the full-image export `docker commit`s the container (refused for an adopted case) and the workspace export `docker pause`s it first (skipped — it freezes the owner's processes for the length of the tar). ⚠️ `owned` is applied AFTER `dockerConfigHash`, which takes an explicit field list, or every pre-existing case would trip the drift gate at once. ⚠️ Run modes for a container case come from the CONTAINER (`availableModes`, live-probed): gating the run menu on HOST CLIs (#201) is right for local sessions and wrong here, since a host with no `claude` may run a container that ships one. ⚠️ **A failed probe means opposite things per ownership** — for an ADOPTED case it is a fault worth reporting, for an OWNED one it is the NORMAL state before the first session (the launch chain creates the container), so treating it as a fault hid every agent mode on every freshly linked Docker case behind "start it yourself first". That is why `CaseInfo.docker.owned` is on the wire. ⚠️ Claude is launched WITHOUT `--dangerously-skip-permissions` when the container's exec user is root (Claude Code refuses the flag as root and the refusal is visible only inside the container); which flag to drop is a per-CLI fact, so it is the registry's `overlays.docker.rootCommand`, never a branch. ⚠️ Adoption is **admin-only in multi-user mode**, unlike `docker-link`: linking creates OUR container, whose one bind mount `isWorkingDirAllowed` has already confined, while an adopted container's mounts belong to its owner and one mounting `/` hands the adopter the host. The same reasoning admin-gates the container listing and the in-container directory browser; the preflight instead admits a non-admin for a container already linked to a case they own, because the run menu probes it for every docker case. ⚠️ On the loopback-only prod bind a container cannot reach 127.0.0.1, so in-container hooks need `CODEMAN_DOCKER_BRIDGE_HOOKS=1`; otherwise idle detection falls back to output-based. → [architecture-invariants#docker-cases](docs/architecture-invariants.md#docker-cases), `docs/docker-cases.md` (user guide), `docs/docker-cases-plan.md` (design)